Joseph Phelps Merlot (Napa Valley) 2002

I was disappointed by this vintage of what is usually a very reliable wine. I found it thin, lacking the rich unctuousness one associates with premium California Merlot. Instead of the bright fruit flavors typical of good young Merlot, it shades toward the earthy mineral end of the spectrum. The Spectator liked this wine a lot, scoring it at 91; Parker was more dismissive, calling it "clipped" and "one dimensional," and slotting it in a range from 85-87. (Links will work only for subscribers.) I'm siding with Parker on this one. Grade: B-